Glenisla   Against   Turbines
  • Home
  • How can I help?
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Links

Press Release - Macritch

4/27/2015

1 Comment

 
PRESSURE MOUNTS AGAINST PLAN FOR WIND TURBINES AT LOCAL RESERVOIR

Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) has lodged a damning objection against the Macritch Hill wind turbine application for Backwater Reservoir. The planned development, for 18 industrial wind turbines each over 400 feet tall, has been criticised by SNH on several grounds. SNH states that it recognises the huge importance of mitigating the effects of climate change by reducing greenhouse gas emissions. However, in the case of Macritch Hill SNH said "We consider it unlikely that, given the sensitive location of the proposal, its detrimental impacts could be reduced or mitigated to a level where we would remove our objection." The objection is particularly significant as SNH very rarely objects to wind farm developments.


This objection, from the Scottish Government's statutory consultee on landscape and ecological issues, adds to those lodged by leading environmental charities including the John Muir Trust (JMT) and International Raptor Research and Conservation (IRRC) and has been welcomed by local groups campaigning against the development.

Last week, a public meeting held at Kirriemuir Town Hall to discuss the development heard a presentation from leading clinical radiologist Dr Rachel Connor, a campaigner against wind turbines sited in drinking water protection areas like Backwater Reservoir because of the risk of water pollution.  Other speakers were Helen McDade, Head of Policy of the JMT, Stewart Miller, Director of IRRC and Graham Lang, Chairman of of Scotland Against Spin (SAS). The meeting acknowledged the need for renewable energy developments but urged against the siting of industrial scale wind turbines in sensitive locations such as Backwater Reservoir, where irrevocable damage to the landscape and destruction of habitats of protected species such as wild cats, and golden and white tailed sea eagles, would result.

Angus Council has also registered objections to the development. Mr Steven Thomson, Angus Council Senior Environmental Health Officer, says in a report that there are doubts about the accuracy of the noise data provided by the applicant and requests that they carry out further site investigations and additional noise measurement.  The applicant has further failed to provide an assessment of the impact on the residential amenity of nearby properties.

He said “This service objects to the application due to lack of information relating to operational wind turbine noise. We will review the objection if these issues are addressed by the applicants.”.

Mr Thomson’s report follows advice from leading acoustic consultant Mr Dick Bowdler, who was asked by the Council to review the applicant’s noise assessment.

Another objection from Mr Thomson is over the “potential impact to private water supplies”. He says that the applicants have failed to carry out necessary risk assessments at two properties.

Sue Smith, spokeswoman for Friends of Backwater and Glen Isla Against Turbines, said that campaigning groups welcomed the robust objection from statutory consultee SNH and from the Angus Council environmental health official. “We believe some of the data ENECO has provided is flawed and the application is quite clearly contrary to the Angus Local Plan. Apart from noise and water issues, the landscape character of this beautiful area would be destroyed and local habitats of many endangered species threatened." She added "The reservoir is a popular and accessible beauty spot which is visited regularly by people from the surrounding towns and cities who are looking for peace and tranquility in the rural countryside."

It has been confirmed that Angus Council will consider the planning application on Thursday May 14 and will then send its recommendation to the Scottish Government. If the Council objects there could be a local public inquiry.

 

 

1 Comment

Update

4/25/2015

0 Comments

 
A most interesting and informative Public Meeting was held in Kirriemuir Town Hall on Thursday evening. Guest speakers were Graham Lang from Scotland Against Spin, Dr Rachel Connor who gave a presentation on the risks to public water supplies, Helen McDade, Head of Policy at the John Muir Trust and Stewart Miller from International Raptor Research and Conservation.


Despite a disappointing public turn out everyone present was given a huge amount of information to digest. This was a really good opportunity to learn more about the damages and risks associated with large industrial wind turbine developments and to see Macritch Hill in the wider context of of the political and economic climate in Scotland.


The message to take away is that we are not fighting local developments in isolation. With the up coming election we all have the chance to be talking to our would be parliamentary representatives and we must raise the question of Scotland's Energy Policy. 


SNH have responded to the Energy Consents Unit and have OBJECTED to the Macritch Hill  development.


Their comments can be read HERE




0 Comments

Date change

4/14/2015

0 Comments

 
The date for the Full Angus Council meeting when Macritch will be discussed has been changed to THURSDAY 14th of MAY

Please put the date in your diary, as much support as possible on the day will show the Council the strength of feeling in the local community.

0 Comments

Meetings!

4/10/2015

0 Comments

 
MEETINGS!

Various important meetings are coming up, do please attend if you can

Friday 17th of April - The Cairngorm National Park Authority is meeting in Ballater and on their agenda is Saddlehill industrial turbine development. The meeting is in the Albert Hall at 11am and members of the public can attend. If you would like to speak at the meeting then you need to arrange this in advance.

Thursday 23rd of April - Public Meeting in Kirriemuir Town Hall at 7pm arranged by Friends of Backwater Reservoir. This meeting is to alert members of the public to the possible risks to drinking water from the proposed development at Backwater Reservoir. Guest speakers are Dr Rachel Connor and Graham Lang (Scotland Against Spin)

Friday 15th of May - The planning application for Macritch will be heard by a Full Council at 10am. Whilst Angus Council are not determining this application they are consultees and their response for the Energy Consents Unit will be agreed at this meeting. Two representatives from the local community can speak for a maximum of 10 minutes but the presence of as many objectors as possible will help to show the strength of local opinion.

0 Comments

    Author

    We are a group of people who live in and around Glenisla and care passionately about this beautiful unspoilt landscape 

    Archives

    February 2016
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.